There is no single canonical origin recorded in the supplied sources. The motif is documented regionally in mining counties of Britain—Cornwall, Devon, Wales and Staffordshire—where miners attributed unexplained subterranean noises to small spirits. The same basic motif travelled with miners and reappears in American mining lore under the name "Tommyknockers." Sources emphasize a family resemblance to Celtic terms such as Welsh coblynau and Cornish Bucca/Bwca but do not provide a single historical point of origin; the tradition is therefore best understood as a distributed occupational spirit-type that adapted to local cosmologies and languages.
Descriptions in the provided material are inconsistent and sparse. Comparative commentary groups knockers with other small, underground spirits and sometimes describes them in dwarflike terms, but concrete, uniform morphological details are not attested in the supplied sources. Where commentators attempt to characterise them, they are treated as small, elusive beings analogous to coblynau (Welsh) or bucca/Bwca (Cornish), emphasizing their subterranean habitat and auditory behaviour rather than a fixed corporeal form.
The defining behaviour attested across sources is producing knocking sounds within mines. Miners commonly interpreted these knocks as warnings—for example, presaging cave-ins or indicating unstable ground—or as signs of a spirit's presence in the workings. Variants in regional lore present knockers as ambivalent: helpful when warning of danger, but in some accounts mischievous or "nasty." Modern cultural usage (noted in the supplied material) expands the motif into fiction and American mining vernacular ("Tommyknockers"), which reworks the theme for literary purposes.

Coblynau
Coblynau (singular coblyn) are small gnome-like mine and quarry spirits from Welsh folklore. They are reported in folkloric summaries as haunting underground workings, making knocking sounds, and—according to some miners' tales—occasionally indicating locations of ore or riches.

Bucca
A class of place‑bound supernatural beings attested in Cornish folklore, associated in surviving sources with coastal and mining landscapes and with local occupational culture; the surviving packet of sources is fragmentary and primarily cites an anthology excerpt (Mabel Quiller Couch).
Community Record
- [1]Knocker (folklore) - Wikipedia. Wikipedia: Knocker (folklore)wiki
- [2]Kobs, Gobs, & Cobs: Folklore as Monsters in Dungeons & Dragons. Backstab Substack: "Kobs, Gobs, & Cobs" (discussion of mine spirits and knockers, noting warning noises before cave-ins)other
- [3]First Knocker Record from Wales - Beachcombing's Bizarre History Blog. Beachcombing's Bizarre History Blog: notes Welsh word 'coblynau' apparently meant 'knocker' toofolk
- [4]What are fairies described like in your countries folklore? (AskEurope Reddit). Reddit / AskEurope (comparative comment grouping knockers with small/dwarflike spirits)other
- [5]Tommyknockers: why the 'tommy' prefix in AmE?. English StackExchange: discussion noting terms Knocker/Knacker/Bwca/Bucca/Tommyknocker as cognate names in English and regional traditionsother
- [6]5 Mysterious Devon Folklore Tales | Spooky Isles. Spooky Isles: includes 'The Knocker' among Devon folklore talesfolk
- [7]Had the legendary 'dwarfs' of Western Europe been associated with Jews before Tolkien (or possibly Wagner)? (AskHistorians Reddit). Reddit / AskHistorians (comparative mention of knockers among 'dwarfs' of Western Europe; secondary commentary referencing Paul Manning)other
- [8]First Knocker Record from Wales (Archive reference list). Wikidata / Wikipedia cross-reference noting Staffordshire usage and relationship to the same phenomenawiki